trans.gif (825 bytes)


Click here for the current status, including text, of HR 623.

On February 8, 1999, Rep. Joe Knollenberg (R-MI) reintroduced his bill to repeal national efficiency standards for plumbing products. The new bill, H.R. 623, had 38 cosponsors: 34 Republicans and 4 Democrats. All of the cosponsors were Members who had previously cosponsored the same bill in the last Congress. There were seven members (all Republicans) of the House Commerce Committee who cosponsored the new bill, including Joe Barton (TX), the new Chair of the Energy & Power Subcommittee. (click here for a current list of cosponsors)

Below is a position statement in support of national standards endorsed by 24 organizations, including plumbing manufacturers, water and wastewater utilities, and environmental groups.

Position Statement on National Water Efficiency Standards

February 1999

The Los Angeles Aqueduct brings less water to L.A. from the Mono Basin thanks to low flow toilets.The undersigned companies, organizations, and public agencies reaffirm our support for maintaining national standards for the water use efficiency of new plumbing products, as provided by current Federal law. From diverse perspectives, we each have come to support this approach to reducing the costs of providing safe drinking water, treating municipal wastewater, and protecting our rivers, lakes, estuaries, and wetlands.

The drought now affecting several portions of the United States serves to underscore the need to make more efficient use of our water supplies. Even where water is not scarce, efficient plumbing products help consumers and communities hold down the rising costs of additional water supply and wastewater treatment infrastructure. Saving water also reduces the energy required to pump, heat, and treat water throughout the nation.

With over half of all indoor residential water use taking place in the bathroom, improved water efficiency in new toilets is central to most water conservation efforts. Several different technologies are employed in the latest generation of water-efficient toilets on the market today. Numerous reports have shown that the great majority of homeowners who have been surveyed are satisfied with the performance of these new toilets. Leading national consumer publications have highlighted many brands and models that meet their performance tests, and utilities that promote the installation of water-efficient toilets have received few complaints.

The rigors of the marketplace will drive even further improvements in the performance of plumbing products. However, the regulatory stability provided by current Federal law is very important to the U.S. plumbing industry. It allows businesses to bring improved products to a national market, rather than spend time and money designing products for differing flush volumes, flow rates, test procedures, certification requirements, and labeling rules, all of which could vary by state and local jurisdiction if Federal standards were repealed. Economies of scale -- an important factor in keeping costs to consumers low -- could be lost if this national market were to become fragmented.

Our message is straightforward: efficient plumbing products work, and efficient water use is an important national concern.

Alabama Rivers Alliance Environmental Defense Fund Plumbing Manufacturers Institute
American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy Friends of the Earth Prairie Rivers Network (IL)
American Supply Association Hampton Roads Water Efficiency Team (VA) Public Citizen
American Water Works Association Heal the Bay (CA) Santa Monica BayKeeper (CA)
Association of California Water Agencies Metropolitan Water District of Southern California Seattle Public Utilities
Charles River Watershed Association (MA) Mono Lake Committee (CA) Southern Nevada Water Authority
Committee on the Middle Fork of the Vermilion (IL) National Association of Plumbing-Heating-Cooling Contractors Union of Concerned Scientists
Environmental and Energy Study Institute Natural Resources Defense Council US Public Interest Research Group

For additional information about this issue, please contact Patrick C. O'Connor of the American Supply Association at 202-223-6222 or Pocatko@aol.com, or any of the above-listed organizations, or visit the links below.